Leaving Baby With Babysitter: Tips for Nervous Moms

This post is all about leaving baby with babysitter.

Leaving Baby With Babysitter: Introduction

Leaving your baby with a babysitter for the first time can stir up a swirl of emotions. On one hand, you know you deserve a little break, whether it’s for date night, errands, or just a few hours to yourself. On the other hand, the thought of someone else caring for your little one (even for a short time) can feel overwhelming for many new moms.

If you’re in this stage, you’re not alone! Every mom experiences a mix of excitement, nerves, and even guilt when it comes to trusting someone else with their baby. The good news is that leaving baby with babysitter doesn’t have to be a stressful experience. With the right preparation and mindset, you can set your child, and yourself up for success.

As a means for providing for my family, I may earn commissions if you shop through the links on this page at no additional cost to you. Thank you!

This post will walk you through how to prepare your baby for time with a sitter, what to communicate with the caregiver, and even how to handle the mom-anxiety that naturally comes with this big milestone. (We also have a perfect babysitter notes template to ensure your babysitter has all of the information they could possibly need!)

Preparing Your Baby (and Yourself) Beforehand

One of the best ways to ease the anxiety of leaving baby with babysitter for the first time is to prepare! Start preparing yourself and your little one in advance. A little planning can go a long way toward making the experience smoother and less stressful.

Do short trial runs

Before leaving your baby for a longer stretch, practice short separations. You might start by leaving your baby with a trusted family member or friend for 20–30 minutes while you step out. These trial runs help your baby adjust gradually, and they also give you confidence knowing your little one can handle it. It could even be as simple as having a friend or family member watch them downstairs, while you stay upstairs working on laundry or relaxing for 20-30 minutes.

Keep routines consistent

Babies, toddlers and young kids thrive on predictability. If bedtime is usually at 7:30, or your little one expects a story before nap, let your sitter know. The more familiar the routine, the more secure your child will feel.

Write down the details

Don’t rely on memory in the rush of getting out the door. Create a simple notes sheet with feeding times, bedtime steps, allergies, comfort items, and emergency contacts. Having everything in writing helps your sitter feel confident and ensures your baby’s routine stays consistent. (I’ll share my Babysitter Notes Template later in this post to make this part super easy!)

Leaving baby with babysitter: Tips for Choosing the Right Babysitter

Finding the right babysitter makes all the difference in how comfortable you feel leaving your baby. The person you choose doesn’t just need to be responsible, they should also be someone you trust and someone your baby feels safe with. Here are a few things to keep in mind:

Trust your gut

Sometimes, everything on paper looks perfect, but something just doesn’t feel right. Your instincts as a mom matter! If you feel uneasy, it’s okay to keep looking until you find a sitter who gives you complete confidence.

Look for experience and training

While every sitter starts somewhere, it can be reassuring to choose someone who has hands-on experience with babies. If your little one is under a year old, ask about infant care knowledge. Bonus points if the babysitter is certified in CPR and first aid. It’s one of those things you hope never has to be used, but provides huge peace of mind knowing they’re qualified.

Ask for references

Don’t be shy about requesting names of families they’ve worked with before. A quick call or message to another parent gives you insight into how the sitter handles routines, emergencies, or even toddler tantrums.

Think about age and personality fit

Some parents are comfortable hiring a responsible teenager, while others prefer an older, more experienced caregiver. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here. It really depends on what feels right for your family and your child’s age.

Schedule a meet-and-greet

While the best case scenario is that you know your babysitter well, that may not be possible for everyone. So before the big night, invite the babysitter over while you’re still at home. This allows your baby to warm up to them in a familiar environment and lets you observe how they interact. It’s a great time to walk the sitter through routines, show them where things are, and answer any questions.

What to Include in Babysitter Notes

Even the best babysitter will feel more confident if you leave clear, detailed notes behind. Having everything written down means there’s no guessing about what your little one needs or when. Plus, it helps you relax knowing the sitter has all the information at their fingertips.

Here are some essentials to include in your babysitter notes:

Emergency Contacts
List both parents’ phone numbers, a nearby relative or neighbor, and your pediatrician’s number. Don’t forget to include your address in case of an emergency call. It’s also a good idea to include the phone number and address for your nearest emergency hospital.

Feeding Schedule
Whether it’s bottles, snacks, or dinner time, note the what and when. If your baby has food allergies or restrictions, make those clear too.

Bedtime Routine
Babies and young kids thrive on consistency. Write down the order of events, bath, pajamas, story, favorite lullaby, etc. so your sitter can stick closely to what your child is used to.

Comfort Items & Soothing Tricks
Does your baby need a pacifier, special blanket, or white noise machine? Share the details that make winding down easier.

House Rules
Screen time limits, snack guidelines, or areas of the house that are off-limits.

Special Notes
Anything else you’d want to mention: medications, nap quirks, or even “the dog barks when the doorbell rings on TV so don’t freak out.”

*MOM TIP*

To make this step easier, I’ve created a Babysitter Notes Template you can quickly fill in before heading out. It’s a printable, ready-to-use sheet that covers all of the above categories (and more). Instead of scrambling to jot things down last-minute, you’ll have a simple, organized page to hand your sitter, giving both of you confidence and peace of mind. You can use the link to edit your information on the computer using a free Canva account, and even add a cute picture of your baby. Or if you prefer, just print the simple template out and write in your information.

Easing Mom Anxiety About Leaving Baby With Babysitter

Even with the most trustworthy babysitter and the best preparation, many moms still feel a knot in their stomach when it’s time to say goodbye. That’s completely normal. Separation anxiety isn’t just something babies go through, moms experience it, too. Here are 5 tips to help calm your nerves when you’re leaving baby with babysitter:

Remind yourself it’s healthy for your baby

Spending time with another caregiver helps your little one learn flexibility, trust, and social skills. You’re not abandoning them, you’re giving them the chance to grow in new ways.

Start small and build up

If this is your very first time leaving your baby, keep it short. Run to the store or grab a quick coffee. Over time, you can work up to longer stretches. Each successful outing makes the next one easier!

Leave clear instructions

Anxiety often comes from worrying, “What if the babysitter doesn’t know what to do?” Having your Babysitter Notes filled out means you can leave without second-guessing. When you know the sitter has all the information, it’s easier to relax.

Set check-in expectations

Decide ahead of time how and when you want updates. For example, ask your sitter to text once your baby is asleep or send a quick photo during playtime. That little reassurance can go a long way without overwhelming either of you.

Be kind to yourself

It’s okay if you shed a tear or feel uneasy at first. It shows how much you love your child, and is totally normal. With time and practice, the separation will get easier. And remember, you’re not just caring for your baby by stepping away you’re also caring for yourself.

Communication Tips With the Babysitter

Good communication is key to making sure both you and your babysitter feel comfortable. So, setting clear expectations ahead of time avoids misunderstandings and helps the night go smoothly.

Be upfront about your expectations
Let your sitter know what’s most important to you. Whether that’s keeping your baby on schedule, limiting screen time, or sending a quick text update. The babysitter can’t read your mind. So be sure to communicate expectations clearly.

Discuss check-ins
Some parents want regular updates, while others prefer only one message after bedtime. So just be honest about what will make you feel reassured without putting too much pressure on the sitter.

Encourage openness
Remind your sitter that you’d rather know if something came up, like a hard bedtime or a skipped bottle, so you can adjust in the future. Creating a space for honesty builds trust on both sides, which is really important for everyone.

End on a positive note
When you get home, be sure to thank your sitter and ask how things went. A quick debrief helps them feel appreciated and keeps communication flowing for next time.

Leaving Baby With Babysitter: Conclusion

Leaving your baby with a babysitter for the first time is a really big step. For both you and your child! It’s completely normal to feel nervous, but preparation, clear communication, and a little trust can make the experience smoother and more positive.

By choosing the right babysitter, preparing your baby with consistency, and leaving clear notes, you’ll set everyone up for success. And don’t forget that your anxiety is natural, but it will ease with time. Each outing helps your child grow more comfortable, and helps you feel more confident as well.

To make things even easier, don’t forget to grab the Babysitter Notes Template. It’s a simple, printable way to keep all your instructions, routines, and emergency contacts in one place. So you can step out the door knowing your sitter has everything they need and more.

At the end of the day, you’re giving yourself the chance to recharge, rest, or reconnect, which makes you an even stronger, happier mom when you return. So everybody wins!

RECENT POSTS